54 S Sewalls Point Road, Sewalls Point, FL 34996

$5,500,000

Gorgeous new build, wide-waterfront home on one of South Sewall's Point's most historic parcels. Built in 2020 on 3/4 acre, this classic modern property offers 4085 sf under air, pool, large backyard, sweeping wide water views and a white sand beach. 4 bd./4.5 bath with an office, bonus game room,… Read More and three car garage. Features include wide plank wood flooring, Sub Zero and Wolf appliances, elevator, generator, impact windows and doors, spacious kitchen, large island, and state-of-the-art security/surveillance system. Outdoor living includes a covered lanai, saltwater heated pool/spa, putting green, plans for outside addition and cabana, and beautiful eastern views of lagoon & Hutchinson Island. Private new dock, 16000 pound lift and completed sewer connection. Must see rare opportunity. Set on one of Sewall's Point's most notable and beautiful wide waterfront sites, this property blends a meaningful past with coastal luxury, perfect for entertaining, relaxing, or watching the sunrise. Once home to the original 1800s Harmer residence with rumored ties to Al Capone, the property now features a custom, no-expense-spared 2020-built home offering refined finishes, clean architectural lines, and exceptional indoor-outdoor living. Bright, open spaces with high ceilings, wide-plank wood flooring, and expansive windows capture sweeping eastern views toward Hutchinson Island, the House of Refuge, the Hutchinson Island Bridge, Bird Island, and the Intracoastal Waterway. The home offers 4,085 square feet under air with four bedrooms, four-and-a-half bathrooms, a library, a bonus game room, and a three-car garage with generous storage and workout configuration. The chef's kitchen includes a Sub Zero refrigerator and Wolf gas appliances, a large center island with storage, custom cabinetry, and seamless flow into the living and dining areas. The living room includes a cozy Chicago brick gas fireplace surrounded by custom built-in bookshelves and mantle. Multiple sliders open to a spacious covered lanai for outdoor lounging or hosting. The home features an oversized 40x20 saltwater pool with dual gas and electric heating capabilities and electronically app-controlled lighting and heating systems. The outdoor dining and lounging areas include a putting green, manicured yet lush landscaping, uplighting, mature palm trees, and an herb garden. The vast and substantial backyard is perfect for outdoor sports or is buildable with included plans for future cabana expansion. The front yard includes an 11-foot mature privacy hedge, a mango tree, a Poinciana tree, and a Magnolia tree. A private dock with a 16,000-pound lift and a dredged navigable slip provides direct access to the Intracoastal, Boy Scout Island, the Sandbar, Sailfish Point, Downtown Stuart, and Jupiter. The dock is constructed with WearDeck composite decking, upgraded lighting, and 10-inch pilings for added stability, with composite materials that offer exceptional resistance to heat and long-term durability. The wide, white sand beach is met by the idyllic waters of the Indian River Lagoon, providing opportunities for dolphin, manatee, and various wildlife sightings. Additional features include an elevator, full house generator, impact windows and doors, and a fully completed sewer connection with new Sewall's Point Road enhancements for a high and dry elevation. This residence combines custom craftsmanship, historic significance, and a premier waterfront lifestyle in one of the most desirable communities on the Treasure Coast. Wonderful for children or retirees, this rare opportunity will not last. Read Less

Courtesy of One Sotheby's Intl. Realty 772-337-8250

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

124

Last Updated

May 2, 2026

Property Type

Single Family Residence

Beds

Full Baths

Partial Baths

Square Ft.

4,085

Lot Size

0.75 Acres

Year Built

2020

MLS Number

R11147412

30 Days Snapshot Of 34996

$473k

+64%

(avg) sold price

-38%

homes sold

140

-22%

(avg) days on market

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Property Access

Road frontage type: "Public Road"

Appliances & Equipment

"Water Softener Owned", "Electric Water Heater", "Dishwasher", "Dryer", "Free-Standing Freezer", "Gas Range", "Ice Maker", "Microwave", "Refrigerator", "Washer", "Water Heater"

Building

Built in 2020, Architectural style: "Plantation", "Traditional", Living area: 4085, Construction materials: "Block", "Fiber Cement", "Metal Siding", Toal building area: 5782

Cooling

"Ceiling Fan(s)", "Central Air", "Electric"

Exterior Features

"Built-in Barbecue", "Custom Lighting", "Outdoor Shower", "Pool Bathroom"

Fireplaces

"Decorative"

Floors

"Marble", "Wood"

Garage

3 spaces

Water Features

Waterfront features: "No Fixed Bridge", "Ocean Access", "Intracoastal", "Navigable Water", "River Front", "No Fixed Bridges"

Heating

"Central", "Electric"

Home Owner's Association

Association amenities: "Park", "Picnic Area", "Playground"

Interior Features

"Bedroom Layout - Split", "Built-in Features", "Closet Cabinetry", "Custom Mirrors", "Elevator", "Entrance Foyer", "Kitchen Island", "Storage", "Walk-In Closet(s)"

Laundry

"Inside", "Laundry Closet", "Laundry Tub"

Lot

0.75 acres

Parking

"Attached Garage", "Covered", "Garage", "Garage Door Opener"

Pets Policy

Pets allowed: "No Restrictions", "Yes"

Pool

"Chlorination - Auto", "Concrete", "Gunite", "Heated", "In Ground", "Salt Water", "Pool Bath"

Property

Patio and porch features: "Porch - Open", "Patio - Open", "Patio - Covered", "Porch", "Patio", "Deck", View: "River", "Intracoastal", Zoning: Residential

Roof

"Metal"

Security Features

"Closed Circuit Camera(s)", "Motion Detector(s)", "Security Lights", "Security System", "Security System Owned"

Sewer

"Public Sewer"

Taxes

Annual amount: $21,205

Utilities

"Three Phase", "Cable Available", "Sewer Available", "Water Available"

Windows

"Blinds", "Drapes"

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

54 S Sewalls Point Road

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send